Where to Stay in NYC in the Fall (Best Hotels by Borough)
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. This means that if you click through and make a booking, we will earn a small commission with no additional cost to you. We would truly appreciate using the links as these small commissions greatly support the blog and allow us to continue sharing our travel tips! We only recommend accommodations, activities, tours, and services that we believe will provide the greatest value for your travel experience.
New York City in the fall? Absolute magic. Between the crisp air, the changing leaves in Central Park, and the pumpkin spice everything, autumn might just be the best season to explore the city. But here’s the thing— choosing where to stay in NYC in the fall can feel extremely overwhelming. Too many options, all slightly different, and somehow you end up stuck. We know the feeling, and we’re here to help you out.
Where to Stay in NYC in the Fall: Best Hotels by Borough for Every Traveler
Whether you want skyline views, cozy boutique vibes, or just somewhere close to the subway, we’ve got you covered. Let’s break it down borough by borough so you can figure out exactly where to crash after all that leaf-peeping and bagel-eating. We will share the best hotels in NYC by borough when traveling during fall season!
Manhattan: The Classic Choice
If you picture NYC in your head, chances are you’re imagining Manhattan. Times Square, Central Park, the Empire State Building—it’s all here. The downside? Hotels in Manhattan can be pricey. But hey, if there’s a season to splurge, it’s fall.
Best Hotels in Manhattan
Why stay here? Because you’ve probably seen it in every NYC movie ever. Home Alone 2 comes to mind for us. Staying at The Plaza in the fall feels like living in your own movie or rom-com. The lobby smells like fresh flowers, the rooms scream luxury, and Central Park is literally across the street. Perfect for those morning walks under golden leaves. Yes, it’s very expensive…
Who’s it for? Travelers who want the full-on “I’m in New York, baby!” experience.
2. The Ludlow Hotel (Lower East Side)
Why stay here? It’s trendy without trying too hard. Think exposed brick, big windows, and killer city views. Plus, you’re steps from some of the best fall food spots (pumpkin ravioli at Lil’ Frankie’s, anyone?).
Who’s it for? Cool kids who love nightlife, craft cocktails, and don’t mind staying downtown.
Why stay here? Because you don’t want to sell a kidney to afford your hotel. This is a much more affordable option compared to the others. CitizenM gives you sleek, modern rooms, a rooftop bar, and a location that makes sightseeing a breeze.
Who’s it for? Budget-conscious travelers who still want style.
Brooklyn: Artsy, Cool, and Surprisingly Leafy
Brooklyn in the fall is like that friend who always seems effortlessly cool. Brownstone stoops covered in pumpkins, indie coffee shops with oat milk lattes, and leafy neighborhoods that make you forget you’re in a massive city.
Best Hotels in Brooklyn
1. The Wythe Hotel (Williamsburg)